About SB-Cal   |   Issues  |  Legislation  |   Successes  |   Resources  |  Join  |  Contact Us  |   Home

Small Business California
2311 Taraval Street
San Francisco, CA 94116
(415)-680-2188

info@smallbusinesscalifornia.org

Small Business Feels the Credit Crunch

 
Oct 3, 2007 11:42 AM , By John Arensmeyer
The sub-prime mortgage collapse is putting small businesses at risk.

 

The news is filled with stories about the sub-prime mortgage debacle and its effects on our economy and on overextended home buyers. But, what is not often mentioned is the devastating effect the credit crunch is having on small businesses.

“Credit, be it credit cards, bank financing, home loans or other sources of capital, is already a big issue for many small businesses,” notes Scott Hauge, president of Small Business California, a small business advocacy organization. “The sub-prime meltdown is having a substantial impact in the credit market, and this is adversely affecting small businesses.”

Surveys Show Adverse Impact and Decline in Business Confidence
Unlike large enterprises, small businesses are disproportionately dependent upon personal sources of credit for funding. A recent survey by the National Small Business Association (NSBA) found that 44 percent of small businesses rely on credit cards as the primary source of outside financing, followed by bank loans (29 percent) and private loans (22 percent). In fact, 71 percent said that they were carrying a month-to-month credit card balance, and 53 percent report that their credit card terms have gotten worse in the past five years. While small businesses are incurring credit card debt, the survey also showed that only 29 percent of small business owners forecast economic expansion for the year 2007, down from 62 percent in the year 2000.

“Because traditional bank loans are difficult for a small business owner to get, and small businesses rely more heavily on personal credit than large businesses, the ramifications of a credit-crunch are significant,” says Molly Brogan, vice president of public affairs for NSBA. “In our survey, we found that when businesses can’t get financing, 40 percent are forced to hold off on expanding their business. Not a pretty picture for entrepreneurs looking to start or grow their emerging business.”

Recent small business surveys by Visa USA, Discover Card and Wells Fargo show similar drops in economic confidence and decisions to postpone capital investments and economic expansion. Thirty-five percent of owners in the Discover Card survey say that recent changes in the housing market have had a significant adverse impact on their businesses.

Businesses Suffer From the Impact on Clients
Martha Doster, the owner of Body Bueno, an Albuquerque, NM, retail store selling body care products, has been forced to use her credit cards in order to finance the recent remodeling of her new store. “Interest rates are going though the roof, credit card terms are tightening up, and affordable financing terms are now impossible to find,” says Doster. “The higher rates mean that I am unable to pay down my balances fast enough, and the onerous terms being offered are putting my business operations at risk.”

 

The credit crisis has had an equally profound indirect effect on small businesses that have clients who are feeling the squeeze, too. Mark Cook owns Cook Networking, an information technology company based in the Washington, D.C. metro area. He says that clients who had been planning technology upgrades or relocations of their offices are now rethinking if this is the wisest time to do so, given rising interest rates. “Clients who were contemplating major system upgrades of hardware are now postponing these plans until a later date or canceling altogether,” says Cook. “This will significantly reduce the number of billable hours we have this fiscal year and will probably lead to a reduction in our staff.”

The problem is not likely to be alleviated anytime soon, particularly with the continued lock-up of the $2 trillion market for commercial paper, a form of debt that financial institutions rely on to raise money for short periods. The recent half-point cut in the federal funds interest rate may help a bit, but will not alter the underlying problem.

What Can be Done?
As long as small businesses continue to be dependent primarily on personal sources of capital, they will continue to suffer.

“Many small businesses don’t want to put up their home as collateral or run up their credit card balances,” notes Kim Blueher, director of lending for WESST Corp, a NM non-profit economic development organization that provides training, technical assistance and loan funds to entrepreneurs. “They want credit based upon their business operations, but traditional banks are not geared toward this type of lending.”

In the past, Small Business Administration (SBA) loans have offered some relief to small businesses. “Although, the flood of foreclosures has caused some lenders to become more risk averse, SBA loans offer a safety net for small firms trying to access the capital they need to start or expand their business,” says Senator John Kerry (D-MA), Chairman of the U.S. Senate Committee on Small Business and Entrepreneurship. “Given today’s market, the SBA and their lending partners need to promote and use these tools to keep affordable credit flowing to businesses in our communities.”

But, policy advocates point to the severe cuts in funding for SBA loans over the past six years as having exacerbated the current problem. “The credit crisis is just one more reason that the SBA core 7(a) lending program needs to be expanded and the cost of a 7(a) loan needs to be reduced,” says Hauge of Small Business California.

Others see the need for long-term structural changes. Proposals have been put forth for a securitized public-private partnership that would ensure a steady source of small business credit that would be based upon the entrepreneur’s underlying business, as opposed to his or her personal assets. “There should be more accessible alternatives aside from maxing out credit cards or taking second mortgages for entrepreneurs who want to start or expand businesses,” says Jonathan Koppell, associate professor at the Yale School of Management, who authored one of the leading proposals. “Collaboration between government and the private sector has gotten millions of American into their own homes. With risk properly managed, we can put Uncle Sam’s creditworthiness to work for American small business at almost no cost to the taxpayer.”

In the meantime, small businesses will need to find creative ways to deal with the credit crunch until it subsides or more long-term solutions are in place.

John Arensmeyer is Founder and CEO of Small Business Majority, a national small business advocacy organization.