Entrepreneurs
California's Health
Care Dreams
Maureen Farrell,
09.27.07, 11:16 AM ET
While Obama,
Clinton and Edwards trot out their plans for giving
all Americans access to health insurance, a working
blueprint for universal health care may be unfolding
far from Capitol Hill.
The state
of California--where 6.6 million people, or 19% of
the population (the highest of any state), are
uninsured--is wrestling with that issue right now.
Earlier this month, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger
called a special legislative session to hammer out a
palatable universal health care bill. Lawmakers
could draft a proposal in the next few weeks.
One deeply
interested party is California's small business
lobby. While small companies provide over half of
America's private sector jobs, many of them can't
afford to offer health benefits--which means they
can't attract the talent they need to compete and
grow.
The rest of
the country is watching too: If passed, the bill
could set the stage for policy battles in other
states and Washington.
"If
California demonstrates that it's possible to get
something done, everyone will take notice," says
Larry Levitt, a vice president with the Kaiser
Foundation, a national health care research
foundation.
Related Links:
The Future Of Universal Health Care
Budget Battle For Tyke Health Care
With health
care costs through the roof and climbing, no one
doubts that something has to give--but who's going
to pay for all that care?
Whatever
plan lawmakers gin up, entrepreneurs in California
will likely feel a sting in the form of stiffer
taxes. The incentive for small businesses to sign
on: In theory, those dollars would help make health
care more affordable for potential employees, thus
leveling the playing field in the struggle to hire
talent away from larger competitors that can afford
to offer insurance. Second-order result: A healthier
population puts a smaller strain on the overall
health care system (emergency rooms and so forth)
and ultimately reduces overall health care
costs--again, in theory.
In the
past, small businesses have bristled at health
care-related tax hikes. But with health care costs
rising 10% or more a year, they too are starting to
listen.
"There's a
sense that something is going to happen," says Scott
Hauge, president of Cal Insure, a health insurance
firm, and president of Small Business California, a
nonprofit advocacy group. "There's a pressure that
wasn't there five years ago."
Two key
proposals are at the center of the California
debate. Both are "play-or-pay"--meaning that either
small businesses offer insurance, or they pay a tax
penalty.
Governor
Schwarzenegger's plan calls for a 4% payroll tax on
businesses with 10 or more employees that don't
currently provide health insurance. The plan also
includes an "individual mandate" requiring that all
residents buy health insurance or face a tax
penalty.
The other
proposal, put forth by Democratic State Assemblyman
Fabian Nunez (called AB 8), is even pricier. Small
businesses--of all sizes--that don't offer
insurance, or contribute less than 7.5% of Social
Security wages (capped at $97,500 for each
employee), would be on the hook for a 7.5% payroll
tax. And unlike Schwarzenegger's plan, all citizens
would not have to buy insurance.
There are
other proposals floating around too. The California
Restaurant Association, for example, has advocated
an increase in the sales tax to subsidize health
care.
While
Schwarzenegger's session is into its third week,
this debate is still in its early stages. According
to quirky California rules, any new tax proposal
must pass in the State legislature by a two-thirds
majority; if not, California residents will vote on
it themselves. That probably won't happen until the
next presidential election. Surely the
candidates--and entrepreneurs nationwide--will be
eyeing the proceedings over the coming weeks and
months.
The hard
truth: Universal health insurance plans will only
achieve so much without other ways of keeping costs
in check, such as pricing transparency, wellness
incentives and limiting superfluous procedures. "If
the state is just putting their fingers in the dyke,
there will be more problems," says Cal Insure's
Hauge. "We don't want to pay into a broken system." |